Handling Login.Authenticate event

Hello,

A) Book I’m learning from says that if we handle Login.Authenticate event, then we have to authenticate users on our own. Thus control won’t automatically validate username and password. I thought book suggested this would only happen if we override Login.OnAuthenticate() method, but it appears that even if only add an event handler for Authenticate event, the automatic authentication doesn’t happen.

But why is that? Why doesn’t event handling work like it does with Init or Load events, where you essentially have to override Page.OnInit() and Page.OnLoad() in order gain control over event handling?

B) I checked MSDN site and it basically recommends that if we do override Login.OnAuthenticate(), we should also call base.OnAuthenticate(). But then, why would we ever need to override Login.OnAuthenticate(), if we get the same effect with simply declaring an event handler for Login.Authenticate?

thanx

From stackoverflow

• You should not override OnAuthenticate. This method is only used internally to either raise the Authenticate event to registered handlers if there are any or authenticate via the current MembershipProvider if there are no handlers registered. So, to implement custom authentication for the Login control, you simply register a handler for the Authenticate event and set the AuthenticateEventArgs.Authenticated property.

  Event handling for the Authenticate event works exactly the same as for other events. The only difference is that the OnAuthenticate method has some logic that determines whether to use a MembershipProvider or a registered event handler for authentication.

  If you do create a subclass of Login and override Login.OnAuthenticate, it is wise to call base.OnAuthenticate(...) because it contains the logic that calls the registered event handlers. If you do not call base.Authenticate(...), you should call the registered event handlers yourself. But creating a subclass of Login is probably not necessary in your situation.

  SourceC : RWWILDEN - Event handling for the Authenticate event works exactly the same as for other events. The only difference is that the OnAuthenticate method has some logic that determines whether to use a MembershipProvider or a registered event handler for authentication.--- So in essence this logic notices that we registered an event handler for Authenticate event and assumes we will handle authentication ourselves and thus cancels automatic authentication?

  Ronald Wildenberg : Yes, that is exactly what happens.

  SourceC : thank you for helping me